← Latest Photography · Opinion

If Nobody Ever Looks at Your Photograph – Is It Still a Photograph?

The validation trap

Of all the global issues fundamentally attributable to the rise of social media, the curse of validation is right up there near the top of the list.

Sure, you could argue that the ‘in my opinion’ era ushered in by Facebook, Twitter and Reddit is worse; that pathological need that the vast majority of people now have to share their two cents on literally any oblique subject that comes floating down the river of sewage that is the modern social media timeline. But I think the curse of validation might be worse – particularly when it comes to artistic pursuits like photography.

At the risk of sounding like some cranky old wanker shouting at clouds, I have strong memories of the before-times when your photographs were rarely glimpsed by anyone other than your old mum or perhaps a couple of close friends. Certainly the number of people who had their photographs widely viewed by the general public was miniscule. So few photographers broke through into the public conscience that (in the UK for instance) Olympus hired ‘60s icon David Bailey for their annual Christmas advertising campaign, along with a supporting cast including James Hunt, Eric Idle and Lord Lichfield.

In fact, the closest that many photographers ever came to a public showcase was boring the neighbours shitless with a Kodak Carousel slideshow of travel photographs taken in Lanzarote, projected onto a sheet hung up in the front room. For most of the history of photography, that was enough – photographs were personal items, very occasionally shared with other people – but mostly destined to sit in unloved albums in the bottom drawer of the sideboard.

Anti-Social Media

It’s hard to imagine social media taking off the way it did, without the ability to share photographs in posts. In fact it could be argued that the arrival of the iPhone and its built-in camera was the real launch date – that pivotal moment in history when every night out became a photo opportunity and every breakfast was documented for an audience that never asked to see it.

Yes, the rest of the planet quickly discovered the joys of photography and meanwhile those of us who’d been enjoying photography for years, suddenly found an audience. Those of us who actually knew our arse from our aperture suddenly had Facebook pages with hundreds of thousands of appreciative fans. The photography influencer was born.

Underneath every post and every photo was that thumbs-up button – the validation button – the approval of your work by some third party on the Internet. Every single like provided a tiny dose of dopamine and over time we began needing those hits just to feel normal. Facebook, Instagram, Flickr, Reddit and Twitter trained us and ultimately rewired our brains to equate likes to quality.

The curse of approval and validation did far more than just turn us all into performing seals of course, it utterly changed photography forever. Because like the well trained idiots that we are, we adapted what we shared, searching for the dopamine hits that were themselves crowd-funded by a corporate algorithm whose real purpose was to show us perfectly targeted adverts.

Photographs on Instagram began trending towards an ‘ideal’ mean. Whatever niche of photography you favour, there’s a median look to a photograph that gets more likes and whether deliberately or subconsciously, photographers began pushing their images in that direction. Hell, photography influencers like Peter McKinnon actively encouraged photographers to change the way they were taking photos, to pick a single style and then stick with it. Because, you know, fuck evolving, and because (Thor forbid!) your Instagram feed didn’t look like the same photograph taken over and over again from a slightly different angle.1

After a few years, once social media had been fully and ruthlessly monetised and after Zuckerberg, for instance, had begun asking page owners to pay2 to reach the audiences they’d organically grown – some of us realised just how toxic an environment it actually was. Posting slowed and, certainly in my case, it pretty much stopped completely.

No idea why I felt the urge to photograph the bin outside our local Aldi’s, but I think it was because of the word ‘Thanks’. Why are Aldi thankful? Because someone decided to kick the door off? Because people keep pushing future-landfill into the top even though it is quite clearly full? But I can categorically state that I’d never have taken this photograph at the height of my social-media period because my photos all needed the stamp of approval from an adoring audience – and who’d upvote a fucking bin? This photograph is far more interesting to me than many of the shots I took when I was in the cult.

At the height of the social media boom, before the pay-to-play systems were bolted on, my photo posts were getting tens of thousands of likes and views, but those numbers disappeared as soon as Zuckerberg began his pay-per-access system and there was no way I was going to ‘boost’ any post just to reach people who’d voluntarily subscribed to my page. But I digress.

The Joy of Self Validation

By that stage I, like most photographers (I suspect) I had been trained to equate the number of likes (or loves on Instagram) with quality. Whether it was a subconscious process or something I actively thought about – the more likes a post got then (obviously!) the better the photograph.

And of course it worked the other way too – if I uploaded a photograph and it garnered very few likes or comments then clearly it was a shitty photograph. Sometimes, I am embarrassed to admit, I would actually delete those ‘under-performing’ posts and resolve never to share that wretched photograph ever again.

My journey back to sanity began about eight years ago, as it slowly dawned on me that social media had turned my photography into an exceptionally poorly-paid job and it was then that I began pulling back.

I asked myself one simple question – what concrete benefits was I gaining from posting on social media? And the answer in my case was that there were literally no benefits to posting on social media. Then I asked myself if there were concrete disadvantages to posting on social media – and I could have filled a small notebook with answers to that one.

I stopped posting on Instagram first. Initially I just stopped uploading there – convincing myself that I had some professional (😂) use for my account – but after about a year I flagged it for deletion and cut myself off from that fuck awful platform completely. I cheerfully jettisoned the ten thousand and something followers I had painstakingly and miserably accumulated over the years that I ran the account. And my mood improved almost instantly. Twitter went next.

After well over a decade of sharing my photographs, I fired the algorithm-generated validation engine on social media and reclaimed the process. I no longer need an online audience, a jury of foreign IP addresses, to rate my photographs3. I have realised once more that the value of a photograph goes far beyond how it actually looks.

My love of photography was nearly stolen by the robber barons of social media and for many years I stupidly believed that hitting that upload button was what finalised the process of a creation – the making of a photograph. But I’m in a much better place now – free of the disease of validation. Most of my work never leaves my computer, but they are still photographs, even though I am likely to be the only person who will ever see them.

1

The only thing worse than McKinnon’s advise on ‘killing it’ on Instagram, was the mea culpa he had more recently where he bemoaned the fact that Instagram had ruined photography – cleverly side-stepping the fact that he had been central to the enshitification.

2

Beyond the money he’s earned selling my most intimate personal details to data brokers, Zuck’s never earned a cent from me – and he never will.

3

I must confess that my Facebook page is still active, but I hardly ever upload there and it too will be gone soon enough. And I still share photographs here on Substack occasionally and I have an active (but very under-used) account on Glass, but those feel more like sharing a diary entry than adding a photo to the global conveyor belt, that near-infinite queue of images all awaiting an utterly meaningless stamp of validation.

The Anti-Subscription

Found this useful? Shout me a coffee, once.

Leave a tip

Also published in RAW & Unfiltered on Substack.

more.

Keep reading. Or don’t, I’m not your boss.